Skip to content
Naked Security Naked Security

Dating app boss sees ‘no problem’ on face-matching without consent

'When you have a bunch of single guys in the office, it goes in that direction', says Dating.AI founder as he dismisses concerns about scraping other dating apps for faces for users to match

A new “dating” — or maybe stalking — app is using facial recognition to help you date people who look like, say, your ex, or perhaps a celebrity, or then again, a random stranger you might have breathed at on the subway.

Why waste time with tedious swiping? Just upload a photo of someone you want to date — including yourself, as BuzzFeed suggests, à la Narcissus — and the app will use facial recognition to scan thousands of profile photos sourced from dating sites and apps to find people whose faces are similar to what you’re after.

Clicking on photos of the face matches will take you to their profiles on Tinder, Match, Plenty of Fish, and other dating apps. The app references don’t specify all the sites it checks against.

But Tinder, for one, doesn’t allow this kind of automated scraping of its API. Tinder told BuzzFeed that the company had “contacted the developer to inform them that the app is violating our terms, and we have been told that they will address the issue”.

Plenty of Fish, which, like Tinder, is owned by Match Group, said that the company is trying to get Dating.ai removed from the iTunes app store.

Heath Ahrens, the founder of Dating.ai, told BuzzFeed that it was “news to me” and that he didn’t see a problem:

If you’re on a dating app, you want to be found.

Ahrens also said that he and his team are “having … a [very] productive conversation with [Tinder]”. He compared the app to the airline industry-disrupting Expedia or Priceline. Instead of “name your own price,” it’s “name your own face”.

Ahrens said the idea for the app came when he and his team were looking around for ways to use facial recognition software they’d developed. After reading about another app that used Tinder’s API — called SwipeBuster, which promises to find out if your partner’s cheating on you with Tinder — they were inspired to use their technology on dating apps.

BuzzFeed quoted Aherns:

When you have a bunch of single guys in the office, it goes in that direction. You wanna try your own dog food.

My, how very Uber of you.

According to the app listing on the Google Play store, the app comes from Haystack AI, which describes itself as focused on Artificial Intelligence Deep Learning Entertainment.

AI. Ah. That’s good to know. For a while there, I assumed it had something to do with Anguilla, the British territory in the Caribbean whose internet country code top-level domain is .ai, which led me to think that maybe Anguilla has different laws about facial recognition technology than here in the US.

As we’ve reported in the past, the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) considers the strongest relevant US law to be the Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act, which prohibits the use of biometric recognition technologies without consent.

In fact, much of the world has banned face recognition software, EPIC points out. In one instance, under pressure from Ireland’s Data Protection Commissioner, Facebook disabled facial recognition in Europe: recognition that it was doing so without user consent.

So yes, depending on where you live, there are laws against facial recognition without consent. It’s not clear whether Dating.ai is breaking any of those laws … just as it wasn’t clear whether an app called Pornstar.ID, which promised to identify porn stars through reverse image lookup, fell foul of these laws.

A few months ago, we reported that Pornstar.ID had trained its neural network on upwards of 650,000 images of more than 7,000 female adult performers. We never did find out if those performers had agreed to having their biometrics scanned so as to train a neural network.

Dating.ai, for its part, lists these selling points on its Google Play listing:

  • First Dating App with Face Search
  • Don’t Waste Time Swiping
  • Find Your Type Fast
  • Free Celeb Search
  • Upload a Photo of Your Ex
  • Take a Photo of a Friend
  • See if You’re Being Catfished
  • Find Your Look-Alike
  • See if they’re on the Prowl

That last selling point is pretty much identical to those pushed by anti-cheating apps  – such as Swipebuster, FlexiSPY and mSpy — which the courts on multiple occasions have interpreted as illegal surveillance technologies. Some users have been charged with wiretapping over their use. The head of at least one such app, StealthGenie, was indicted for selling spyware in October 2014.

I reached out to Dating.ai to ask if the developers are aware of laws that criminalize facial recognition without consent; what steps, if any, they’ve taken or could take to ensure that their app isn’t used by abusers to stalk current or ex partners; and for a comment on the need to protect people’s privacy and their right to freely associate without being surveilled.

I’ll update the article if I hear back.


9 Comments

Never used one of these sites due to the issues they have, but this one seems highly sketchy on one of it’s selling point… ‘Upload a photo of your ex’. As an example if an ex of mine decided they wanted someone that looks like, then the site is happy for her to upload ‘my’ photo with no consent from me to a dating website, or a photo of someone she may like who also hasn’t given consent. Whether for ‘training’ or whatever isn’t the point. We’ve seen how some of the details of people have be taken from dating websites on Naked Security before, so it’s not like they are trustworthy with safeguarding data. Now people who look similar to a person someone may fancy or be an ex of someone is going to have their photo floating round on someone’s server without consent or knowledge it’s been done. Sounds highly dodgy to me. I can almost hear the opening of canned worms.

Reply

Upload a photo of YOUR EX???? So, in addition to finding people you want to “date”, apparently this app also lets you get revenge at the same time, and just a few clicks away. Who cares about those pesky restraining orders?

Reply

“upload a photo of your ex”

Larry Miller:
That’s like eating your breakfast in the morning and saying “Ew, this milk is SOUR!”
(puts it back)
Well… maybe tomorrow it’ll be fresh!

Reply

Okay, “upload a photo of your ex” and “see if they’re on the prowl” is solidly in the stalking realm.

Reply

Is it good for anything? Well, you could stalk an ex and find him/her, even if a new name was being used.

Reply

Here’s a thought to give you the willies: this is the perfect tool for the serial killers who go after a very specific type of victim – one who looks like someone from their past.

Reply

Given the penchant for dating sites to create fake profiles, the provision of “free” photos must be a godsend…

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to get the latest updates in your inbox.
Which categories are you interested in?
You’re now subscribed!