Skip to content
Naked Security Naked Security

Facebook crushes 583 million fake accounts in 3 months

On a daily basis, it disables millions of fake accounts before they ever hatch.

On Tuesday, Facebook took yet another stab at transparency in these days of users’ and politicians’ outrage.
It came in the form of the first release of the company’s Community Standards Enforcement Report, and it was stuffed with the type of detail that Mark Zuckerberg told so many Congresspeople he’d need to get back to them on when he was first lightly sautéed and then flame-grilled in two days of testimony.
For years, Facebook has had Community Standards that explain “what stays up and what comes down.”
Last month, for the first time, Facebook published the internal guidelines it follows to enforce those standards.
Tuesday’s release of the first ever Community Standards Enforcement Report is a way to hand over the numbers that have resulted from that enforcement. With that information in hand, Facebook’s thinking goes, we can all judge for ourselves how it’s doing when it comes to getting rid of all those fake accounts and their spammy output… And posts with nudity. Or sexual activity. Or hate speech. Or terrorist propaganda.
Guy Rosen, Facebook’s vice president of product management, said in the post that the company’s disabled about 583 million fake accounts during the first three months of this year, or between 3% and 4% of monthly active users. It’s taken down nearly 1.3 billion over the past six months.
The majority of fake accounts were blocked within minutes of registration, Facebook said, touting its artificial intelligence (AI) auto-flag, auto-destroy technologies. On a daily basis, it crushes millions of fake accounts before they ever hatch.
Take down the accounts, and you’re on the road to wiping out the spam they spew, 837 million pieces of which Facebook found and flagged in Q1 2018. Nearly 100% of that spam was discovered and flagged before anyone reported it, Facebook says.
Taking down fake accounts is important not just to fight spam. It’s also crucial for battling fake news, misinformation, bad ads and scams. For example, following Facebook’s F8 developer conference, the company said that it’s started to use AI to automatically sniff out accounts linked to financial scams.

Numbers on other types of violative content:

  • Facebook took down 21 million pieces of what it considers to be adult nudity and sexual activity in Q1 2018. It found 96% of titillating content before it was reported. Facebook estimates that out of every 10,000 pieces of content viewed on Facebook, just seven to nine views were of content that violated its adult nudity and pornography standards… which, by the way, have a history of head-scratching decisions. A few years ago, Facebook found itself having to clarify just what non grata “nudity” is. TL;DR: it has to do with the nuances of nipples.
  • For graphic violence, Facebook took down or applied warning labels to about 3.5 million pieces of violent content in Q1 2018, 86% of which was identified by AI before users reported it to Facebook.
  • Hate speech is a tough one, not just for Facebook but also for Twitter, YouTube and other platforms. Facebook says its technology “still doesn’t work that well and so it needs to be checked by our review teams.” It removed 2.5 million pieces of hate speech in Q1 2018, 38% of which was automatically flagged before it saw the light of day.

Rosen echoed what Zuckerberg said at F8 recently: “we have a lot of work to do to prevent abuse.”
For example, spotting hate speech is complex, as Rosen described in a detailed post following F8.
From Tuesday’s post:

Artificial intelligence isn’t good enough yet to determine whether someone is pushing hate or describing something that happened to them so they can raise awareness of the issue.

AI also needs to be trained with large amounts of data to recognize meaningful patterns of behavior. Facebook doesn’t always have that much training data, particularly in less widely used languages.
All in all, the report is Facebook’s latest bid to pull itself out of the post-Cambridge Analytica mess it got itself into…
…a user data-sharing fiasco that’s already chalked up two more misbehaving apps: besides Cambridge Analytica, we got a second app posing as a research lamb that turned out to be selling our data to the marketing wolves, and then, this week, we got yet another research app that left users’ intimates out on the laundry line, unsecured, for four years.
But Facebook’s got much, much more to dig itself out of besides the app agonies. For example, one imagines that many of the questions that this report tries to answer have to do with the 2016 US presidential election manipulation spree, replete as it was with Russian trollery, fake news and political ads illegally purchased by overseas entities.
And that’s just part of a more overarching question: namely, is Facebook now too powerful? And can it even keep up with what it calls “sophisticated adversaries who continually change tactics to circumvent our controls?”


They are also closing legitimate accounts. If you don’t have friends or pictures.


And not closing obvious fake accounts. I get a steady dribble of those fake Facebook sirens attempting to flirt. I report them but always get the “nice try but just ignore them” message back from Facebook.


The sirens are out of control. And it’s not like they should be hard to catch automatically – reverse image search would take care of most of them.


I’ve had several fake Facebook accounts for years. Each account has a circle of friends and I treat them kind of like an online forum. I guess because these accounts are created by hand and I occasionally visit them, they are real accounts, just under fake names, obviously fake names like the one I am using here.


How many active users does Facebook have?
Going by the numbers in the article, there are more facebook users than people. Or is this like Twitter where each of the downing street cats has their own account?


Nice job zuckerberg fb almost turned into a social media network for any sort of sin, I almost started calling it sinbook


Great idea, just started it, marketed it for 30 min, sold it for 600k.. I’m going to take the afternoon off


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to get the latest updates in your inbox.
Which categories are you interested in?
You’re now subscribed!