Skip to content
Naked Security Naked Security

Facebook throttles antagonistic, drive-by ‘fake name’ reporting

The real-name policy is staying, but it's slowly getting better.

After getting slammed by critics for over a year with regards to its real-name policy, Facebook on Tuesday hugged it tight, saying yet again that the policy’s not going away.

But it is going to get better: starting on Tuesday, Facebook users in the US for the first time got the ability to add context to what’s hitherto been barebones reporting and verification functions.

Now, as Facebook’s blog post illustrated, reporting an account prompts Facebook to ask for more details so that it can understand the problem and gives four options with examples:

  • The profile doesn’t represent a real person. Examples: a fictional character, a profile made with pictures of models.
  • They’re using my or someone else’s name or photo. Examples: your name, a friend or celebrity’s name.
  • They’re using a name that they don’t go by in real life. Examples: a name that no one calls them.
  • Other

It also requires people who report accounts to help Facebook understand the problem by providing details.

That’s one of the tools Facebook’s initially testing in the US in pursuit of two goals: reducing the number of people asked to verify the name they use on Facebook when they already use the one people know them by, and making it easier for people to confirm their name if necessary.

Up until yesterday, reporting a supposedly “fake” name on Facebook has been as easy as the social media equivalent of a drive-by shooting.

That’s resulted in individuals and groups – including journalists and human rights activists – being antagonized with en masse account flagging.

An extensive list of others harmed by the real-name policy was provided by The Nameless Coalition, which in October penned an open letter (PDF) to Facebook explaining why the policy is broken and how Facebook could mitigate the damages it causes.

Facebook’s also testing a new tool that allows for more context when it comes to people having to verify their names.

The tool lets such people inform Facebook of a special circumstance and again gives the company more information about their particular situation and helps its review teams provide more personalized support.

The tool presents these options, plus the optional choice of providing more context:

  • Affected by abuse, stalking or bullying
  • Lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender or queer
  • Ethnic minority
  • Other

The two new tools follow several other changes Facebook’s made to the real-name processes over the last year, including expanding the options and documents that can be used to verify a name.

It’s also started to roll out a new process in which people will have access to their account for seven days while they verify or update their name, as well as implementing additional security protections for documents that people share when verifying their name.

The Nameless Coalition had asked Facebook to provide users with the ability to submit the information using PGP or another common form of encrypted communication, so that their identity information would be protected during the submission process.

Facebook responded by promising that IDs submitted as part of the identity verification process would be encrypted when they’re temporarily stored on its servers.

This is all just the start, Facebook says.

From Facebook’s post, written by Justin Osofsky, Facebook’s vice president of Global Operations, and Todd Gage, product manager:

These improvements are only the beginning. Early in the new year, we will be looking at other ways we can reduce the number of people who have to go through an ID verification experience, while preserving the safety of other people on the site.

We will also continue to work on making the experience itself more compassionate and easier to navigate. Throughout this process, we will continue our ongoing conversations with the Facebook community so they can share their thoughts on improvements they’d like to see.

One of the most vocal critics of Facebook’s real-name policy, San Francisco drag queen and community activist Lil Miss Hot Mess, told Business Insider that she’s “cautiously optimistic” about the changes.

I’m cautiously optimistic about Facebook’s 'real names' improvements — they’ve been [a] long time coming and the devil will be in the details. It’s great that Facebook is finally taking steps to reduce 'fake name' reporting as a form of cyberbullying used to silence marginalized communities.

Facebook says that the new tools are now being tested on a limited basis in the US only, across mobile and desktop. Based on feedback, they’ll be rolled out globally.

Image of fake id courtesy of


Sorry but the biggest problem on Facebook is the mountain of fake profiles used by trolls and spammers to litter up every comment area that uses Facebook for commenting. The ability to report those is limited and Facebook’s reviewers appear to ignore spammers who are called out on their fake profiles and pages.


I have friends who are teachers or law enforcement who do not use their full names. Glad to see they’ll be allowed to continue.


The facebook real-name “policy” is pretty irrelevant anyway. The reality is that you can report fake profiles which are easily verifiable as being World Of Warcraft or similar MMO character accounts and nothing is done. Same goes with profiles using silly lewd names and profile pictures pulled from the web. Again, verifiable by anyone in about 10 seconds flat but they receive approval when reported.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to get the latest updates in your inbox.
Which categories are you interested in?
You’re now subscribed!